UnionBlend

A place to discuss teaching, learning and instructional technology

EduCause 2009: Dinner with Jim Collins (not really)

November 17, 2009 · 1 Comment · Teaching and Learning

Dinner with Jim
Near the end of Jim Collins Good to Great and the Social Sectors talk at EduCause 09, Jim did something a little bit unusual. He asked each of us in the very large amphitheater to turn around and form small groups of 6, and then he gave the following task:
Imagine we’re all having dinner this evening, and you’ve got a chance to ask me a few questions about Good to Great in the Social Sector, what would you ask? After you talk to your group, you’ll have a chance to send one of your group members up to the microphone to ask your favorite questions.
This task was interesting for a few reasons:
* It effectively broke down a room of several hundred people into small working groups
* It gave participants a chance to answer each others questions (our group had a Jim Collins fan who was able to clear up a few points that we found confusing)
* It provided “prepared participation” – allowing participants to practice articulating their questions on each other before sharing them with the large group
* It created a “question filter” where groups of 6 chose their best/most relevant questions before sharing with the larger group
It made me wonder if a similar technique might work in large lecture class. Would 10 minutes of small group question filtering make a difference? Would it help a class get key questions asked and answered? At a base level, would it dramatically increase the number of questions asked during a lecture? (I’m guessing it would!) Would it increase retention and/or engagement? If groups came up with more questions than could be answered in the remaining class time, could they be saved/submitted in some way? Would a question voting mechanism be useful? Perhaps something like Google moderator?
I thought the technique worked pretty well for Jim. In a future post, I’ll try to run through a few of the dinner questions the audience had for Jim, and my notes on their answers.

Near the end of Jim Collins Good to Great and the Social Sectors talk at EduCause 09, Collins did something a little bit unusual. He asked each of us in the very large amphitheater to turn around and form small groups of 6, and then he gave the following task:

Imagine we’re all having dinner this evening, and you’ve got a chance to ask me a few questions about Good to Great in the Social Sector, what would you ask? After you talk to your group, you’ll have a chance to send one of your group members up to the microphone to ask your favorite questions.

This task was interesting for a few reasons:

  • It effectively broke down a room of several hundred people into small working groups
  • It gave participants a chance to respond to the groups’ questions (our group had a Jim Collins fan who was able to clear up a few points that we found confusing)
  • It provided “prepared participation” – allowing participants to practice articulating their questions on each other before sharing them with the large group
  • It created a “question filter” where groups of 6 chose their best/most relevant questions before sharing with the larger group

It made me wonder if a similar technique might work in large lecture class.

Would 10 minutes of small group question filtering make a difference? Would it help a class get key questions asked and answered? At a base level, would it dramatically increase the number of questions asked during a lecture? (I’m guessing it would!)

Would it increase retention and/or engagement? If groups came up with more questions than could be answered in the remaining class time, could they be saved/submitted in some way? Would a question voting mechanism be useful? Perhaps something like Google moderator?

I thought the technique worked pretty well for Collins. In a future post, I’ll try to run through a few of the dinner questions the audience had for him, and my notes on their answers.

Tags: ···

One Comment so far ↓

Leave a Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image